Amaz0ns

AlexG

Global Moderator
Site Superhero

Gender:

Posts: 4734

The Last Defender of Camelot

Poll One – Personal Preference – A Story’s Length

« on: May 01, 2005, 09:13 AM »

The poll pertains, I would say more to the readers since there are far more of them then there ever are writers, but both are welcome to participate since I expect both sides of the aisle would interested in the results. Comments, especially from any writers – actual or prospective - would be also interesting.

Note: This is assuming an “easy-on-the-eyes” reading format of one-and-a-half line spacing and Normal, Times New Roman characters set at size twelve font.

Update: In the light of Jimmy's question I probably should add a caveat that the number of pages refers to how it exists for printing/publication in a word processing program (i.e. MS Word) rather then how a story appears if its posted onto a forum page. This was a factor that I naturally assumed was understood as a given.


	Logged

"Your quality will be known among your enemies, before ever you meet them."
Kingdom of Heaven (2005)

"Reality is things are they are, not as we would wish them to be."
~ Chuck Harder

Garyguy

Site Regular

Posts: 30

Poll One – Personal Preference – A Story’s Length

« Reply #1 on: May 01, 2005, 11:53 AM »

I most often like to read short stories, but I find that I want more out of a lot of the good ones, which is why long stories can work out well sometimes.


	Logged

osquip

Pillar of the Community

Posts: 57

Poll One – Personal Preference – A Story’s Length

« Reply #2 on: May 01, 2005, 01:34 PM »

There are some great stories out there, both long and short. Assuming consistant story quality, my preference leans more toward the longer stories. It allows the author to build on established characters and settings more, and you get a better feel of continuty (or disruption of continuity as changes begin to occur).

Plus, longer stories also usually mean either muscle changes from multiple women, and/or slow, gradual muscle growth - both of which are favorites of mine!


	Logged

minimanmax

Pillar of the Community

Gender:

Posts: 64

Poll One – Personal Preference – A Story’s Length

« Reply #3 on: May 02, 2005, 01:01 AM »

Me I like eather long or short as long as it can keep my interest and is writen well. If it is long it could be broken down into chunks That just seems to make things easyer on me.


	Logged

JimmyDimples

Site Superhero

Gender:

Posts: 1065

Duhhh...

« Reply #4 on: May 02, 2005, 01:19 AM »

I'm still not quite sure where exactly Power Play fits in this category. Someone give me a clue?


	Logged

Being powerful is like being a lady. If you have to tell people you are, you aren't. --Margaret Thatcher

Who's writing this issue... the geniuses behind She-Hulk? --Strong Bad

marknew742

Global Moderator
Site Hero

Posts: 339

Poll One – Personal Preference – A Story’s Length

« Reply #5 on: May 03, 2005, 05:39 AM »

I think Power Play is a long story. What makes it long are:

1. Sustained and consistent plot, character development and style, and
2. its length

All long stories should be broken up in chapters. That's what most "real" novelists do, and it makes it easier for readers and writers alike. Readers can stop and rest at the end of chapters. Writers have to stop for breath frequently.

I think bad long stories are much worse than bad short stories. Part of that is, of course, the length. More importantly, it's harder to find the good parts. Double entendre intended.

I find 5 pages normally too short to accomplish much more than set a mood.

Beyond that, I like both formats. If the story is really good then as a reader I want it to go on and on. As a writer, it's a house I'm enjoying living in and I don't want to move out too soon. But some themes don't extend well and should be kept short. For me, some stories are good for one or two ideas, one or two twists, one of two good parts. The effect would be lost if they were repeated. Others, like Jilly Milly, needed extended development to bring out all the implications.


	Logged

Pages: [1]