- This topic has 3 replies, 4 voices, and was last updated 18 years, 4 months ago by
00tree.
-
AuthorPosts
-
February 27, 2007 at 7:22 pm #47943
Chuck
ParticipantI know I posted in the growth section about who your favorite FMG superheroine is, but this one's different:
In a four-way matchup between She-Hulk, Caitlin Fairchild, Power Girl, and Wonder Woman, who would win?
Considerations: She-Hulk and Caitlin Fairchild might have the edge smarts-wise over Power Girl and Wonder Woman; She-Hulk is an accomplished lawyer and Fairchild used to be an uber nerd before her transformation.
Also, as if to balance it out, Wonder Woman is an amazon princess, so you know they've been trained to fight since birth. And if she's pushed hard enough, she will bring down lethal force on you!
Power Girl's advantage… she's like a busty female version of Superman lol.
Me, I'd have to give it to She-Hulk. She was trained by Captain America and Gamorra, the deadliest woman in the universe, so in addition to being smart, she'd also know how to bring the hurt.
Let the ultimate throwdown commence!
February 27, 2007 at 8:44 pm #47944
AlexGKeymasterMuch as I love She-Hulk (and all of them for that matter, to one degree or another), in a knock down, dragout, no holds barred, take no prisoners, no quarter given or asked for Wonder Woman (the only real warrioress in the lot – and potiently ruthless, coldly so) probably would clean all of their clocks, tho not without serious damage to herself – would be something of a Pyrrhic victory.
“I like a good story well told. That is the reason I am sometimes forced to tell them myself.”
~ Mark Twain / Samuel Clemens (1907)February 27, 2007 at 11:08 pm #47945Prophet Tenebrae
ParticipantYeah, I'm a big She-Hulk fan but the fact of the matter is that Wonder Woman and Powergirl totally outclass her… I'm not sure who would win between WW and PG but it would be close… let's just have them wrestling in maple syrup instead, wouldn't want any of them getting hurt.
February 28, 2007 at 9:43 am #4794600tree
ParticipantThere are many factors that would come into play here. I don't think Caitlin would fare to well against the other women named here. Not enough killer instinct and her power level is usually not seen as to high in any of the comics she's in, even her own. She Hulk is the strongest mortal woman of the marvel universe meaning she'd not that strong compared to a DC character even with her boosted strength and fighting skill (?????? it's hard to tell with the current writer, when she gets showed up in here own comic by you guessed it wolverine. yes the man who has to be in every other marvel comic has struck again).
Now here's where it gets tricky. power girl and wonder woman seem to be at the same power level now. With Power Girl's (for lack of a better term) power decrease way back in JLE made her as Demetri aka the Rocket Red, rest his soul, a pail shadow of her former self, the writers did this so that she didn't out shine the rest of the team. and with wonder woman's power increase of the last five years or so it would be a close one. I would have to say that power girl should win but the DC editors wouldn't let it happen. (Oh no not our precious Wonder Woman) don't get me wrong WW is a cool character but she has to use her bracers or you could blow her head off with a few well placed shots. I don't care how fast she is if you shoot her with a mini gun that shoots 8000 rounds a minutes she isn't gonna block them all. But since she is an original character and as much as i hate to say it Power Girl is just a female version of another character DC will give the fight to WW. Hey at least its not as bad as having a normal dude like batman (again I love the character but he's waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay over powered) beat guys that he really has no business fighting with a batterang like it's easy.
Those are my thoughts…
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.