[10-4]

I’m liking these. They are looking mighty good.

[SammiChung]

A) There are ways to express criticism without always coming across like a complete douchebag. Learn how. It isn't that difficult for anyone who can function in everyday society. Maybe then the people here who actually offer something worthwhile won't react the way they do to your "critique".

B) There is a monumental difference between offering an informed critique, and presenting your personal (and seemingly baseless) opinion as FACT. Again, learn how.

C) I just don't like you. This is because you come across as an odious, maladjusted cretin (or worse, purposely want to be seen as such). This is my OPINION, but you can treat it as a CRITIQUE if you want. Because if no one critiques you, how do you expect to fucking IMPROVE?

amen amen especially after the four letter tirade I got directed at me (I will not repeat it, and sexual orientation aside wether I AM A FEMALE or not is clearly none of his g-damn businesss anyway) in #femalemusclefurries mIRC chat  its nice to see more people stand up to an ass such as MuffinMan/Canis'.

[Ashlee]

great work it sooooo cute, she take the giants keys and bend them into
pretzels. Hopefully around Goofy's head.LOL

[smitty]

A) There are ways to express criticism without always coming across like a complete douchebag. Learn how. It isn't that difficult for anyone who can function in everyday society. Maybe then the people here who actually offer something worthwhile won't react the way they do to your "critique".

B) There is a monumental difference between offering an informed critique, and presenting your personal (and seemingly baseless) opinion as FACT. Again, learn how.

C) I just don't like you. This is because you come across as an odious, maladjusted cretin (or worse, purposely want to be seen as such). This is my OPINION, but you can treat it as a CRITIQUE if you want. Because if no one critiques you, how do you expect to fucking IMPROVE?

I'm siding with Muffin Man on this one. I don't necessarily like the guy, but he made an observation. That's all. It wasn't nasty, it wasn't mean-spirited (whereas some of his other comments have been).

To me, the artist's reaction was worse … much worse.

smitty

[The Muffin man]

amen amen especially after the four letter tirade I got directed at me (I will not repeat it, and sexual orientation aside wether I AM A FEMALE or not is clearly none of his g-damn businesss anyway) in #femalemusclefurries mIRC chat  its nice to see more people stand up to an ass such as MuffinMan/Canis'.

These two places are completely unrelated. So leave them that way.

And as Smitty said, I would have been MEAN if my response was meant to be meanspirited.

[CONDORMAN]

I'm siding with Muffin Man on this one. I don't necessarily like the guy, but he made an observation. That's all. It wasn't nasty, it wasn't mean-spirited (whereas some of his other comments have been).
To me, the artist's reaction was worse … much worse.
smitty

What are you muffinman's alter ego? Didn't you find any humor in my reply? Editing wikipedia and "Too White and Nerdy" Come on man! Pop culture references used as insults, that is better than the lousy picture that started this thread. You must not have watched the youtube video. Besides I looked at his previous posts and that is what motivated my reponse. In fact, I was just getting warmed up and had to hold back.
http://amaz0ns.com/component/option,com_smf/Itemid,135/topic,3848.msg34904/#msg34904
http://amaz0ns.com/component/option,com_smf/Itemid,135/topic,3848.msg34843/#msg34843
and then this from lingster was the Coup de grâce.
http://amaz0ns.com/component/option,com_smf/Itemid,135/topic,3026.msg29565/#msg29565

Those who fail in art and literature critique.

[Lu]

Those who fail in art and literature critique.

I can't agree with that. When I critique (which is RARELY since so many take it as a personal insult) I'm just trying to help someone out when I see something I feel, personally, is off about the image.
I wouldn't have said I failed at art. But then I guess that's your call isn't it?

[AbyssPlanet]

Frankly, I think I'd care more about Muffin Man's art critiques if he actually contributed art to the forum.

[Author]

Posts