[missmonstermuscles]

The_Collector_2 your reply is filled with anger and resentment, which I will not address.

[Tigersan]

This is sport is full of  DOUBLE STANDARDS , when judging Female Bodybuilders.

Does anyone ever critique genetically male bodybuilders as being attractive or not. . Personally, I think not.
Most male bodybuilders are judged by their muscularity , not their attractiveness .

Yes i agree, however im not a judge 🙂 I'm a person that likes FEMALE bodybuilders. And we here are not
judges either. I understand that some people find that attractive thats perfectly fine. Just don't expect
from everyone to see it that way. I personally like them big but with "mainstream way" cute/hot faces…

So in this particular discussion i think we should set apart 2 things: our personal likings and way of
judging. Because as much as I may like some bodybuilders, they dont have what it takes to place high.

My 5 cents

[Tigersan]

I agree with collector on one part of what he said. Because i think everyone of us has right to like whatever they want. However it hurts
to see how some women make this sport look bad… because EVERY SINGLE time mainstream media use a female bodybuilder image/actress
they pick the ones that look most like men (well not always but mostly)… Bodybuilding is about hard work and dedication and not about
getting obscene amounts of muscles in short period of time making a face look like not even a man. European bodybuilders are the best example
of doing the hard work the "longer" way, patiently sculpting their bodies – thats bodybuilding for me.
When i was at arnold's Classic Europeans were: Cuter and more defined, better conditioned, and had better quality muscle, and proportion.
Yet they werent judged too good… beyond me. Seems like the idea of Bodybuilding has been lost somewhere in that "musclerace".

So what really hurts me personally in fbb as a sport, is that really good looking women (in bodybuilding terms) – conditioning, size, proportion, definition.
dont place high…

Judging in NPC is simply bogus… they promote competitors based on how popular they are and, how many times they shown their face on the shows.
Not based on what they look… thats how it really works. Its fun for them, i was a witness to a conversation of one figure girl that got instructions
from a judge to tone down her shoulders a little and come harder next year. Next year she did and didnt place high and the judge sad something totally different.
*CoughBullshit.

[Tonus]

Annie R. has 0 implants and she still looks like a beautiful female!

Alina Popa also looks feminine and attractive despite not having implants.  I think that implants usually look bad on a female body builder who is in contest shape, because they look so odd and unnatural.  In off-season shape they can look very nice.  But I agree that female body builders do not need them to look feminine.

And let's face it, Caroline Wang would still look unusual with breast implants, due to the appearance of her face.  It's just the luck of the draw, IMO.

[Trash Boat]

Off-Topic: who is that gorgeous girl in your avatar, missmonstermuscles?

Tigersan: that's why I sometimes hate sports where the results are based on judging; they just seem to have no clear line in their doings.

[The Muffin man]

Her name is freaking Caroline Wang for chrissake. We had to have seen this coming.

[cpbell0033944]

I'm dropping out of this thread now – and, if we start getting too much more of this nonsense, I'm going to drop out of the forum alltogether, or just comment on the art boards.

[MaxxC]

For those Massive, Androgynous, Thick and HUUUUUGE Caroline Wangs out there, there ought to be a federation for their own that rewards that type of look and has a business model that's designed to make money marketing that look. Then they will have that type of success. I can imagine a Renne Toney being the best FBB of that style. Does she look sexy? To me, sure, (as I love hugeness and power) though I never met the gal before. Don't know about everything else though.

If those type of women want to succeed in the NPC which has its own style, they have to conform or bring a new level of the existing standard. Plain and simple. The problem is that because the NPC / IFBB is the largest, most reputable out there (and I use those terms with a grain of salt), every type of competitor wants to be the best in there.

But, in the end, only the bodies that the majority likes and works for the masses will win in the IFBB as BB is a subjective sport.

I found older pics of Ms. Wang here by the way, for your reference.
http://www.beepworld.de/members21/caro80/

[BlackKusanagi]

Hehe. Not to take things off topic a little…but she kinda reminds me of Drago. XD

[chris10000]

  Hell even the biggest one Iris Kyle still looks like a woman and she is HUGE.

iris kyle isnt the biggest..but the best

[Author]

Posts